How to Get Your First Buyers and Sellers on a New Marketplace
Launching a new marketplace? Learn how to attract your first buyers and sellers, solve the chicken-and-egg problem, build trust and generate your first transactions on a limited budget.

A new marketplace faces a difficult question: buyers want enough sellers to choose from, while sellers want evidence that buyers are ready to spend. Planning to spend heavily on advertising before solving that problem can leave a founder/entrepreneur with thousands of visitors but very few completed transactions.
The solution is to start with a small, clearly defined market, recruit the participants needed to serve it, and prove that buyers and sellers can successfully complete transactions. Whether you are building a home-services platform, freelance marketplace, property platform or delivery business, your first goal is not to look big. It is to become useful to a specific group of people.
1. Understand the marketplace chicken-and-egg problem
A conventional online store can begin selling its own inventory. A marketplace must persuade independent sellers to participate while giving customers a reason to return. This is the classic chicken-and-egg problem. According to NFX's marketplace research, founders can tackle it through focused niches, initial incentives, partnerships and even manually connecting the two sides.
The core focus is between sign-ups and liquidity. A seller who registers but never responds to a request adds little value. A buyer who visits but cannot find an available provider is unlikely to return. Measure progress by whether suitable buyers can find reliable sellers and complete transactions, not simply by how many accounts your platform has accumulated.
2. Decide which side to recruit first
There is no universal rule that every marketplace must recruit sellers before customers. The right starting point depends on which side is hardest to acquire and what makes the service valuable.
Consider three examples:
Home services: Recruit reliable plumbers, electricians and cleaners in one service area first. Customers need confidence that someone qualified can actually accept their booking.
Freelance services: Start with a few credible and reliable specialists or secure a client with a real project, then recruit the professionals needed to deliver it.
Local delivery: Coordinate and organize participating merchants, delivery capacity and customers within a compact service zone. Signing up restaurants across an entire city is not useful if orders cannot arrive on time.
If sellers are the scarce resource, focus on supply and If you already have access to a community of buyers or a large customer account, use that advantage to recruit the suppliers needed to serve them. Identify your principal constraint rather than trying to grow both sides indiscriminately.
3. Start with a narrow market, not a big launch
A marketplace that claims to serve everyone often struggles to serve anyone particularly well. Choose one customer segment, category, neighbourhood or specific use case. A property marketplace might begin with verified rental listings in one part of a city. A tutoring platform could focus on mathematics for High School students before adding every subject and age group.
A smaller market makes it easier to recruit relevant suppliers, understand customer objections and fix service problems quickly. It also makes your marketing more precise and narrow to a group. Instead of advertising a general platform to thousands of people, you can tell a specific audience exactly what problem you solve and why your service is worth trying.
Expand when you have noticed consistent demand in the initial market, not simply when your website is ready for more categories.
4. Recruit your first 10–20 sellers personally
Your first suppliers should be selected for reliability and relevance, not just their willingness to register. Identify 10–20 potential providers through industry associations, professional communities, local businesses, referrals and direct outreach. Speak to them individually. Explain who your first customers are likely to be, how transactions work, what fees apply and how you will help them earn revenue.
Make joining worthwhile. You might offer free initial listings, reduced commissions for early transactions, onboarding assistance or better presentation of their services. Set clear limits on incentives so your early economics do not depend on permanent subsidies.
Most importantly, learn what prevents sellers from participating. Is it distrust, complicated onboarding, payment delays, uncertain demand or the fear of paying for leads that never convert? Solve those objections before increasing recruitment.
5. Find your first customers before buying lots of traffic
Your earliest buyers are more likely to come from direct relationships than from a large advertising campaign. Contact people already experiencing the problem your marketplace solves. Demonstrate a practical customer-acquisition framework; showcase the platform in relevant online communities, speak with potential users, ask existing contacts for introductions and build partnerships with organisations that already reach your target audience.
Give prospective customers a clear reason to act now: available providers, transparent prices, unfiltered reviews, a straightforward booking process or a service they cannot easily find elsewhere. Do not promise extensive choice if your supply is still limited. A small, trustworthy selection is better than hundreds of outdated listings.
6. Use manual matching before automating everything
Founders sometimes spend months building recommendation engines, sophisticated dashboards and automated workflows before they know whether customers will transact. At the beginning, you can often match buyers and sellers yourself. When a customer submits a request, contact suitable providers, confirm availability, communicate the options and follow the transaction through to completion. This approach reveals practical problems that software alone may not expose: providers who respond too slowly, unclear pricing, mismatched expectations, unreliable delivery or customers who abandon the process.
Manual matching should not be the permanent operating model. It is a way to learn what needs to be automated and what standards the platform must enforce. You can build the technology incrementally. Entrepreneurs and founders can explore guides to building an app with AI on how founders can use AI-assisted development to reduce some early product-building costs.
7. Market your marketplace on a small budget with AI
You do not need to hire a full marketing agency before testing your first campaign. Affordable AI tools can help you produce useful promotional assets, but they cannot replace customer research, distribution or a compelling offer.
Start with a simple weekly content plan: demonstrate the problem, introduce a supplier, show how the marketplace works, answer common questions and share genuine customer feedback with permission.
Tools worth exploring include:
ChatGPT or Claude: Draft outreach messages, customer interview questions, landing-page copy, email sequences and variations of advertising headlines. Review all outputs for accuracy and brand voice.
Higgsfield: Its marketing tools support AI-assisted product ads and UGC-style video creative. Founders can test different concepts without arranging a full production shoot for every variation. Check current plans, credits and commercial-use terms before committing.
Motion: Useful for planning marketing tasks, organising campaign work and protecting time for consistent execution. It is primarily a productivity and scheduling tool, not a substitute for an advertising platform or a dedicated AI video generator.
AI-generated demonstrations can be essentially useful when showing an app that is not yet widely used. Create a short screen walkthrough, explain a common customer problem and demonstrate how the proposed transaction works. However, do not present a fictional customer, fabricated review or simulated transaction as genuine evidence. Label illustrative demonstrations appropriately, and use real testimonials to build integrity and credibility.
8. Build trust before trying to scale
A marketplace depends on trust because users are often dealing with people or businesses they have never met. Establish clear provider requirements, explain how verification works, display accurate prices and make cancellation, refunds and dispute resolution understandable. Collect feedback after completed transactions and investigate recurring complaints.
Do not use fake reviews, invented listings or artificial activity to make the marketplace appear busier than it is. Misleading users may generate initial curiosity, but it can destroy the trust needed for repeat business.
Partnerships can also accelerate early growth. A property platform might work with reputable agents or property managers; a freelance platform could collaborate with professional communities; a delivery marketplace could partner with merchants that already have customers. Look for partners who bring real participants or transactions, not just a logo for your launch announcement.
9. Measure completed transactions before expanding
Your early dashboard should answer five practical questions:
How many customer requests receive a suitable response?
How long does it take to find an available provider?
What percentage of requests become completed transactions?
How often do cancellations, disputes or failed matches occur?
Do buyers return, and do sellers continue receiving worthwhile business?
Also track acquisition costs and the contribution margin from completed transactions. If you spend more to acquire a customer than the business can reasonably recover, additional traffic may increase losses rather than improve the company.
10. Expand only when the first market works
Once your initial market produces reliable transactions, use what you have learned to enter the next location, customer segment or category. Document the onboarding process, supplier standards, customer support procedures and marketing messages that work. Then test whether those methods transfer to the next market. A successful launch in one city does not guarantee identical results elsewhere.
For founders operating in multifaceted cultures, this discipline is especially important when operations span different cities or countries, where logistics, payment preferences, infrastructure and local trust can vary significantly. The objective is not to create the appearance of a continent-wide marketplace overnight. It is to build a repeatable system for making transactions happen in one market, then reproduce it responsibly.
The bottom line
A marketplace grows when it reliably solves a problem for both sides. Recruit the participants you need most, focus on a market small enough to serve well, help the first customers transact and use their feedback to improve the experience.
Spend money on advertising when you know what happens after the click. Until then, direct outreach, partnerships, manual matching and carefully tested AI-assisted content can help you learn without committing to a large marketing budget.
Your first milestone is not 1,000 users. It is a repeatable process that brings the right buyer and seller together and gives both a reason to return.
Read more: Are LinkedIn Ads Worth It for B2B Businesses? What the Data Reveals About ROI and Sales
Read more: Google Ads vs Meta Ads vs TikTok Ads vs LinkedIn Ads: Which Is Best for Your Business?
Read more: Can Solo Founders Raise Venture Capital? What Investors Want Before Writing a Cheque
Read more: What Is Your Startup Really Worth? Why AI Companies Can Command 50× Revenue While Others Get Far Less
Read more: AI Makes Building Easier: Execution Is What Turns Ideas Into Companies
Author
Azeez LiadiAzeez is an AI Engineer, Data Scientist, founder, and Senior Tech Writer at Afritech Connect. A top 1% graduate of Lagos State University, he has worked with international startups and… Explore author & articles





